State Sovereignty Under Siege
For decades, conservatives championed the idea that power should remain with states and local governments. But Trump’s latest actions tell a different story: one where the federal government overrides local decision-making to serve his personal and political interests. From blocking New York’s congestion pricing plan to interfering with California’s water management, his administration is aggressively consolidating power in ways that undermine democratic governance.
It’s not just state-federal conflicts. Trump’s executive orders are trying to reshape public life—defunding medical research, banning trans athletes, and threatening corporations with federal retaliation. These moves don’t just target blue states. They erode institutional checks and balances, weaken local governance, and normalize executive overreach.
This newsletter examines Trump’s direct clashes with states, the downstream effects of his executive orders, and the broader implications for democracy.
Trump’s Federal Power Grab: What It Means for States and Cities
The Trump administration is making a dramatic shift from traditional conservative support for states’ rights by using federal power to override local decision-making nationwide. From New York City’s transportation policies to California’s firefighting efforts, cities and states are finding their authority challenged by unprecedented federal intervention.
- Transportation: Trump has revoked federal approval for New York City’s congestion pricing program, which aimed to lessen Manhattan gridlock and fund public transit improvements. This move is most likely illegal, but that appears to be of little concern to Trump: “Congestion pricing is dead,” the White House gloated in a post on X. “Long live the King!”
- Emergency Management: Trump made several dangerous and legally questionable decisions regarding California’s water crisis and disaster relief. He ordered the release of 2.2 billion gallons of irrigation water with almost no notice, threatening communities and wasting vital resources, while also pushing to drain the San Francisco Bay Delta based on false claims about LA’s fires. Additionally, Trump has threatened to withhold disaster relief for the LA fires unless California requires voter ID and creates new water regulations.
- Immigration Enforcement: Trump has renewed his first term’s attacks on sanctuary cities by attempting to coerce states into cooperating with immigration enforcement, which the Tenth Amendment explicitly prohibits. His administration’s threats to withhold Department of Justice funding–a tactic attempted and mostly blocked by courts in his first term–is yet another example of Trump trying to override local democratic decisions when they do not align with his administration’s agenda.
States’ ability to respond to local challenges, cities’ control over their own infrastructure, local law enforcement autonomy, and community-specific policy solutions are all at stake.
Trump’s Federal Power Grab: What It Means Beyond Government
The onslaught of the Trump administration’s executive orders and policy changes has impacted far more than federal, state, and local governments. In reality, Trump’s policies are impacting universities, hospitals, and businesses in the private sector.
- Funding for Medical Research: The Trump administration announced it would lower the funding level for major research institutions conducting crucial medical research. Many of the nation’s leading institutions, including Duke, Johns Hopkins, and Harvard, have warned that cuts to NIH funding would jeopardize critical research and innovation and even cause some smaller institutions to shutter their medical programs altogether–not to mention the inevitable fallout for local economies, some of them in red states, that rely heavily on the medical and science sectors. That, combined with the looming threat of a federal funding freeze–which has already pummeled health clinics, community health centers, and health nonprofits across the country–would deal yet another blow to the medical industry while exacerbating the public health crisis brewing at the governmental level.
- Hospital Policy: Hospitals are also denying care following Trump’s executive order that threatens to withdraw federal funding from the hospitals and clinics that provide life-saving, gender-affirming treatment. Hospitals are left to choose between losing a major funding stream, complying with state and federal anti-discrimination laws that prohibit discrimination on the basis of sex, and saving people’s lives.
- Private-Sector Diversity Efforts: Some of the country’s largest private sector businesses have begun to roll back their commitments to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives following Trump’s executive order halting federal DEI programs. This abandonment of business practices intended to address systemic barriers and build more diverse workforces is not required by Trump’s ban, but certainly seems to have been inspired by it. Trump’s anti-DEI order is further bolstered by the DOJ’s threats to sue and criminally investigate private sector DEI programs, which has emboldened state republicans to follow its lead and is actually part of a longer-waged war against corporate efforts to diversify and equalize their workplaces.
Other Federal Power Grabs to Be On the Lookout For
- Federal Takeover of a City: Last week, Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah) and Rep. Andrew Ogles (R-Tennessee) seized the political moment to reintroduce a bill that would strip Washington, D.C.’s nearly 700,000 residents of the right to self-governance and place the city under full control of Congress. Such legislation has been attempted before, but many fear that the bill might have legs this time around, given the Republican trifecta and the current climate. Trump, who campaigned on overseeing a “federal takeover of this filthy and crime-ridden embarrassment to our nation,” and who has recently turned his sights to local institutions within the city like the Kennedy Center, now plans to follow up on the bill with an executive order that would call for a crackdown on homeless encampments and increased criminal penalties for violent and non-violent crimes alike (despite historic lows in the city’s crime rate).
- Immigration Enforcement: The current administration has not been shy to intervene in cases that capture Trump’s interest, but its DOJ’s recent order to dismiss the corruption case against New York City Mayor Eric Adams that raises alarms after the US attorney on the case alleged that the move was not merely strategic, but part of a quid pro quo agreement in which Adams would agree to cooperate in Trump’s plan to crack down on immigration. Trump has employed a variety of tactics to pressure local elected officials into submission, but such an explicit use of DOJ powers signals an escalation. Indeed, mere days after the DOJ order, Mayor Adams announced that the sanctuary city would reverse course and allow ICE access to the city’s jails.
Courage in the Spotlight
- Protests against the Trump regime have erupted across the country and at the forefront are students who are likely too young to even recall much of Trump’s first term, including high schoolers hailing everywhere from Houston to Colorado, and college students from Indiana to Los Angeles. This groundswell emerges even as schools have been thrown into the line of fire of multiple cultural wars and student dissent comes at increasingly high costs.
- The fight against Trump is being waged not only in the streets, but inthis country’s courtrooms, with some of those battles potentially poised to head to the Supreme Court. Among the approximately 50 legal challenges filed thus far are lawsuits in defense of migrants ordered to be transferred to Guantanamo Bay, transgendered people who seek passports, healthcare, permission to serve in the military, and appropriate placement in jails, and the millions of Americans who have fallen victim to Elon Musk’s tailspin efforts to rummage through troves of sensitive information, gut the federal workforce, and defund federal agencies without congressional permission. For a more comprehensive list of the community groups, advocates, unions, and local officials who have joined forces to combat Trump’s agenda, click here.
Support Our Work
We know you have a million deserving places you can support, but we hope you will consider us. You can donate to Wren here.